Check your Story Pulse book cover - teal with a drawing of the heartbeat line and the heart
Check Your Story Pulse

Be true to your story

An illustration of an opem book with a line that leads out, holding a brain illustration and a lightbulb

Developmental Edit

Your manuscript, seen clearly and a map to make it better.

You’ve written it. Maybe rewritten it. You know something isn’t working but you’re too deep inside it to see what, or you suspect what the problem is but aren’t sure how to fix it without pulling everything apart.

Developmental editing for fiction writers works differently from any other kind of editing, and that difference matters. It doesn’t touch your words, but looks at the bones: structure, character and story arc, stakes, emotional payoff, and genre fit. The things that determine whether a reader stays up too late, feels something they weren’t expecting, and tells a friend.

This is for fiction writers (novels, novellas, and short stories) who are ready for an honest, expert read and a clear path forward.

What You’ll Get:

A comprehensive editorial letter (6–10 pages)
This is the heart of the edit. Not a list of challenges, but a thorough in-depth analysis of your story’s foundation: structure, character and story arc, stakes, emotional payoff, and how well your story delivers on its genre’s expectations.

Every observation comes with an explanation of why it matters on the story level, because understanding the why is what turns feedback into genuine craft development. You won’t just know what to fix. You’ll understand what it means for your story, and how to approach it.

Inline comments throughout your manuscript

Specific, targeted notes directly on your pages with examples. If a scene needs more emotional interiority, I won’t just say so – I’ll show you, in that specific scene, one way to bring it onto the page. My comments are designed to illustrate principles, not just point at challenges.

A Zoom call to unpack it together

We talk through the feedback, you ask every question you need to ask, and we make sure you leave the call with full clarity on how to improve your story.

A clear revision roadmap

The editorial letter closes with prioritised next steps, what to address first and what to watch out for as you revise, so that you leave with a clear plan.

Additional tools and resources where relevant

Specific to your story or references that speak directly to the challenges your manuscript presents. They are designed to help you improve your manuscript.

How it works

You arrive with a manuscript that almost works and a feeling you can’t quite name.

You leave with clarity: what’s working and why, what needs attention and why, and the concrete tools to address it. No vague encouragement. No ‘show don’t tell’ without showing you exactly how, in your own pages.

That understanding  (not just what to fix but why it matters)is what makes revision feel purposeful instead of overwhelming.

Pricing is based on project length, because a short story and a 100,000-word novel are genuinely different amounts of work, and I want the investment to feel fair.

Project Length Price Call
Short story Up to 8,000 words $275 30 min Zoom
Novella 10,000–40,000 words $700 60 min Zoom
Standard novel 40,000–80,000 words $1,700 90 min Zoom
Longer novel 80,000–120,000 words $2,400 90 min Zoom

If you aren’t able to invest in a full developmental edit, you can inquire about a manuscript assessment. This budget friendly version still gives you the big picture view of all the strong and weak points of your manuscript, but without the detailed markup language in the manuscript itself.

Who it's for:
  • Writers with a complete or near-complete manuscript who want to know clearly what's working and what needs to change and why
  • Writers who've revised multiple times but feel like they're going in circles without understanding what the real issue is
  • Writers preparing to query agents or self-publish, who want to make sure the story is as strong as it can be
  • Short story writers preparing for submission, competition, or collection
  • Writers who want feedback that is genre-aware, emotionally intelligent, concrete, and genuinely useful, not just a list of issues to address.
Who it's not for:
  • First drafts that haven't been revised at all (give it a few passes so you get more value out of this)
  • Writers looking for proofreading, copyediting, or line-level polish
  • Writers who want someone to rewrite the story for them
Availability:

A developmental edit of 80 000 words typically takes about three weeks from the day you submit the materials. I'm currently fully booked. You can join the waitlist and find out when a new spot opens (most likely in January 2027)

Share This

“Meeting Karmen was the best thing that could have happened to my writing at a critical moment. I had finished a manuscript and didn’t know what to do next. Karmen assessed it, highlighted its strengths, pinpointed the exact weaknesses, offered concrete solutions, all the while expanding my writer’s toolbox.

What I really loved was that her feedback was based on a genuinely invested and highly nuanced understanding of the themes that my writing explores. With her help, I feel like I’ve dramatically improved my manuscript and I’ve taken the next step in my goal to become a published writer. For anyone who takes fiction writing seriously and needs help developing their writing, I highly and warmly recommend working with Karmen.”

~ Admir Skodo
Speculative Fiction & Short Story writer

“Karmen is an excellent book coach. I had been struggling with my first novel for five years and was close to abandoning it as a ‘practice novel.’ Karmen deployed just the right blend of insightful critical analysis and encouragement to show me I had a story worth telling and how to fix it.

Receiving any kind of editor’s report is always daunting, but Karmen broke down the next steps I needed to take into manageable chunks and renewed my confidence in not only my story but my writing ability.”

~ JL Copeland
Horror writer

You may also be interested in...

Mini Manuscript Evaluation

A quick assessment of your story gives you clarity you need to revise with confidence.

One-on-One Book Coaching

A creative partnership from your idea to a finished novel, with honest feedback and support at every step.
Share This